Treatise 2010

The International Thought Challenge

Does the epithet “Sone Ki Chidiya” hold true for India still? Any attempt to capture the ...
We present our argument in favor of the statement that India must first prevail over ...
India, a nation of 1.1 billion people, has been always disproportionately unsuccessful at the Olympics. ...
There’s a raging debate today whether FDI in India drives growth or stunts it. Direct ...
Congratulations ! The following 7 teams have been selected for phase 1 of Treatise (in alphabetical ...
15 COPs, 17 years of climate talks and a new misaligned group formed each year, ...
Timelines for Submission Submission of Preliminary Articles December 26, 2009, 23:59:59 hrs IST Announcement of Shortlisted Teams January 1, ...
Prizes to be won at Treatise The winning team would be declared as “The International Thought ...
In the hour of crisis, the mortals find solace in spirits and the men search ...
We would like to present our argument  that while the metaphor ‘Sone-Ki-Chidiya’ might have been ...
Defending the proposition “FDI fuelled growth of India is sustainable” There is no doubt that the ...
BASIC: Flash in the Firmament The progress of large developing countries has fuelled the muse of ...

Archive for December, 2009

Topic 3 – The Carbon Standoff

Posted by Team Manfest On December - 17 - 2009 Comments Off

“…climate change negotiations have become less about fashioning a truly collaborative global response to a planetary challenge and more about safeguarding and promoting competitive economic interests.”
Shyam Saran – India’s special envoy on Climate Change

While prima-facie it appears that it is the west which is playing a high-handed role in deciding the rules of the game on the emissions turf, the emerging economies too have been acting evasively. When the engine of the world’s growth is the emerging economies, it is, perhaps, time they stopped acting as the deprived younger sibling.

Download Treatise Article 3

Topic 2 – Does the metaphor “Sone ki Chidiya” still hold true for India?

Posted by Team Manfest On December - 17 - 2009 Comments Off

Throughout history, India has remained at the forefront of evolution, development and growth.  Viewed through glasses tinted with science and mathematics, literature, arts, or trade and commerce, the country seems to represent the fountainhead of knowledge.  Hence the metaphor, “Sone ki Chidiya”.  But in recent times, this metaphor has assumed wider implications.  Do these implications represent an oxymoron of sorts?  Do we have reason to believe that this description holds as true today as it did a few centuries ago?

Download Treatise Article 2

Topic 1 – FDI fuelling India’s growth: How long will it last?

Posted by Team Manfest On December - 17 - 2009 Comments Off

There are many economic models which may be used to characterize and determine the rate of growth of an economy.  The one which projects the golden growth trajectory of India employs Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) as a pivotal factor.  In analyzing this growth model, the question of sustainability needs to be asked.  Such an all-round analysis of this model throws up unexpected answers, with not every answer being as rosy as previously thought.  Is India really heralding the new age of a global shift in economic power?
Download Treatise Article 1

Prizes to be Won

Posted by Team Manfest On December - 17 - 2009 Comments Off


Prizes to be won at Treatise

The winning team would be declared as “The International Thought Champions”

Prize money of INR 50000 would be awarded to the winning team

Runners up will be awarded INR 20000

Prizes worth upto INR 5000 can be won by non-finalists/non-participants for posting their comments on the 7 topics (No limits on the number of comments posted by an individual)

Timelines

Posted by Team Manfest On December - 17 - 2009 Comments Off


Timelines for Submission

Submission of Preliminary Articles December 26, 2009, 23:59:59 hrs IST
Announcement of Shortlisted Teams January 1, 2010
Final Round begins January 7, 2010
Submission of castle defense
Start of Rebuttal Phase January 9, 2010
End of Rebuttal Phase January 15, 2010, 23:59:59 hrs IST
Submission of Closing Argument January 18, 2010, 23:59:59 hrs IST
Final Result Announced January 26, 2010, 23:59:59 hrs IST

download treatise timelines

Rules and Format

Posted by Team Manfest On December - 16 - 2009 Comments Off

Event Details

  • The event will be held in two phases
  • First phase
  • Teams are required to submit a well researched article arguing either for or against any one, two or all of the topics provided at Debate Topics link
  • However, each team can submit only one article per topic
  • The document (in pdf/doc format) must be uploaded at treatise.iimlmanfest.com (submit entry link) and mailed to treatise@iimlmanfest.com in and must be named as _.pdf/doc
  • E.g. For a team named Halo submitting an article on the first topic, the document must be named as: 1_Halo.pdf

  • Select articles will be published on the Treatise portal after submission
  • On the basis of the submissions, the top 7 teams will be shortlisted for the final round
  • Second phase – details provided in the attached document
  • The winners will be declared as “International Thought Champions”
  • Prizes: Winning Team: INR 50,000 | Runners-up: INR 20,000 | Phase 2 Comment prizes worth INR 5,000
    Participation

  • Participation in this event is open to all, irrespective of occupation, age and nationality
  • Participants are required to form teams of up to 3 members
  • Members of a team need not be from the same institute/organization
  • One participant can be a member of only one team
  • Registration is not required for participation
  • Please see the attached document for more rules and regulations

Download Treatise Rules and Format

Phase I Results

Posted by Team Manfest On December - 16 - 2009 Comments Off

Congratulations !

The following 7 teams have been selected for phase 1 of Treatise (in alphabetical order):

Cartoons

Sugandha Singh (IIM Calcutta), Preet Pillai (IIM Calcutta)

EaglesSecret

Sagar Goel (IIM Lucknow), Abhishek Sahoo (IIM Lucknow), Sarananth N (IIM Lucknow)

Gotama’s Men

Mahendhiran Chinnappa (IIM Lucknow), Bhuvaneshwaran Velusamy (IIM Lucknow), Arvind Raj (EPFL, Switzerland)

India

Mritunjay Kumar (IIFT-Kolkata), Sankalp Chhabra (IIFT-Kolkata), Seeona Pani (IIFT-Kolkata)

Kurukshetra

Abhilash Sridharan (IIM Bangalore), Vivek R (IIM Bangalore), Geraj Vinny Rajesh (IIM Bangalore)

Team Me, Myself & Chotu

Sharad bhatia (IIM Lucknow), Hitesh Das (IIM Lucknow), Piyush Bhomiya (IIM Lucknow)

XLent_warriors

Muthuraja Palaniappan (XLRI), Ravishankar Kalluri (XLRI),

All The above teams have to send their confirmation of participation to treatise@iimlmanfest.com by 23:59:59 IST on January 2, 2010. Failing this, one of the following teams will be selected as finalists (in the order displayed.)

Wings of Fire

Sugandha Srivastava (IIM Lucknow), Dheep Joy (IIM Lucknow), Narendra M (IIM Lucknow)

VClick!

Ashwini Rao (IIM Ahmedabad), Surabhi Shankar (IIM Ahmedabad),

ZEPHYRUS

Arka Sengupta (Amity Business School), Abhishek Roy Choudhary (Amity Business School), Soamavo Dutta Chowdhary (Amity Business School)

Waitlisted teams are also requested to send an email to treatise@iimlmanfest.com to confirm their participation in the situation that one or more of the finalist teams chooses not to carry on.